Genesee vs. Paleovalley
Genesee vs. Paleovalley: Bison Tallow Bar or Bone-Broth Bar?
Paleovalley's Superfood Bars build on grass-fed bone broth protein; Genesee builds on bison tallow plus whey isolate. Both skip seed oils — the difference is the protein engine and the fat story.
Cancel anytime · Free shipping over $70 · 30-day money-back
Paleovalley earned its audience with organic, whole-food sourcing. Genesee competes on a different ancestral thesis: bison tallow as the structural fat, 21g protein per bar, and dessert-grade flavors built for athletes rather than snackers.
Ingredient-label honesty
Genesee vs. Paleovalley — Side-by-Side
Label claims pulled directly from each brand's published nutrition info.
| Genesee★ OURS | |
|---|---|
| Protein per bar | 21 g |
| Seed oils | None |
| Bison tallow | ✓ |
| Gluten free | ✓ |
| Artificial sweeteners | None |
| Ancestral-sourced fat | ✓ |
| Tallow source | Bison |
| Positioning | Wild-range bison |
Protein per bar
21 gGenesee ★ ours
Seed oils
NoneGenesee ★ ours
Bison tallow
✓Genesee ★ ours
Gluten free
✓Genesee ★ ours
Artificial sweeteners
NoneGenesee ★ ours
Ancestral-sourced fat
✓Genesee ★ ours
Tallow source
BisonGenesee ★ ours
Positioning
Wild-range bisonGenesee ★ ours
Label claims current as of 2026-05-23
Frequently asked
What makes bison tallow different?
Bison were grass- and forage-finished on open range for 200,000 years. Their fat carries a fatty-acid profile shaped by that range, not by a feedlot corn-and-soy diet. It's closer to what humans ancestrally adapted to burn than any seed oil.
Are Genesee bars subscription-only?
No. You can buy one-time or subscribe and save 20%. Skip, swap, or cancel in one click from your account page.
Do you ship outside the U.S.?
Not yet — we ship anywhere in the U.S. with free shipping over $70. International expansion is planned for 2026 Q3.
What's your guarantee?
30-day money-back on every order, subscription or one-time. If you don't love the bars we refund — no questions, no restocking fees.
Take it further
Built for these athletes
Eat it like this
Try the bar we built to beat the shelf.
21g grass-fed protein. Zero seed oils. Grass-finished bison tallow. Subscribe and save 20%, or use the first-box page to pick your starting flavor.